Professor Jem Bendell

notes from a strategist and educator on social and organisational change

TEDx Talk on the REAL cause of the Financial Crisis

Posted by jembendell on October 2, 2011

On September 30th I gave a talk at TEDxTransmedia, in Rome, about the real story behind the financial crisis. The video will appear soon, but here is a transcript I wrote up….

“I’m going to rip apart your ideas about money. I’m going to show you how, behind the headlines on the financial crisis, and behind the ecological and humanitarian crises, lies a hidden crisis. That is, a crisis in our monetary system. A crisis in the way our money is created. I’m going to reveal to you how some people are using the latest technologies to create sustainable currencies, that serve us, not the banks, and how you can get involved.

To understand how the way money is created affects our lives, I’d like you to do a thought experiment. Imagine you are living in a village way way back in time. Lets say 3000 years ago. Some of you look after chickens, some of you fix clothes, some of you bake bread. You all swap things amongst yourselves. Then one day an Imperial Knight arrives to your village. He suggests you use his tokens to trade with. You decide to give it a try, so he lends you each 10 tokens. This is great, you no longer need to directly swap your eggs for their loaves. Your transactions are faster and you have way more time. The Knight agrees you can keep the tokens with one condition – that he has the option to take from you 11 tokens at the end of the year, or seize your assets if you default. As you find the tokens so helpful, you agree. A few months go by, and then suddenly you realise you need to have 11 tokens to show the Knight. So you start asking for more tokens to fix their clothes, and you start hoarding them. You find some of your neighbours are doing the same, so there are suddenly less tokens circulating and people wont swap their stuff so easily. On one day you even go hungry, but at least you feel safe with your 11 tokens. Then the Knight returns and of course not everyone has 11 tokens, and one of your neighbours loses his farm to the Knight. Could you have come to see the tokens as wealth, rather than your relationships, your community, and your local environment as your wealth? Could it be that the technology of tokens or “money” has transformed how you relate, what you value, and how you even feel about life?

Fast forward 3000 years and our monetary system is like that, but on cocaine; literally, if some reports are to be believed.

The Bank of International Settlments

Whatever you work on this is critically important to you. For 16 years I’ve helped large companies, charities and UN agencies team up to address global challenges, like over-fishing, deforestation, child labour, and HIV/AIDS. We’ve created some cool coalitions that improve the social and environmental impacts of billions of dollars worth of business worldwide. But after all this work, some of us have come to realise that if we want to widespread and lasting change, in the way business does business, we have to change the way money makes money.

Now there aren’t yet many clients or funders on monetary issues, so to work on it more, I had to outsource myself to India. There I worked with the association Community Forge, which provides free open source software for communities to run their own currencies. I learned there are thousands of alternative currencies around the world, created by communities. Some use a unit of hours, some mirror the national currency. And advances in social networks and mobile payment systems means we could soon be using alternative currencies for all manner of goods and services, both locally and across the world. Soon you will be able to go into your local store and pay the bill in an alternative currency with your phone, by sms, web or near field communication. It’s already happening in some places, like Brixton in London, which launched such a system yesterday.

I’ll return to say more about these currency innovations, but first, what was key for me in India was I had a variety of myths about money exposed. Someone asked me “where does money come from?” I’m a Professor, of management not economics, but still, its a very simple question and I was stuck. I thought money comes from governments. Well no, in nearly all countries of the world, about 3% of money comes from government mints, that make the notes and coins. Because of something called fractional reserve banking, 97% of money is simply numbers on computers, created from nothing by private banks, when they issue loans. Did you think that when you get a loan from a bank that they actually have the money they lend you? Well no, they create it out of nothing when we borrow. As banks create the loan, but don’t create the interest to be paid on that loan, there is more debt in the world than money. So we still owe more tokens to the Knight than there are tokens to give. So although individually we might pay off our debts, collectively we are in debt forever. Collectively, we are paying compound interest forever.

This causes many problems, but for time, ill mention just two. One problem is that paying interest on perpetual debt means increasing inequality is a mathematical certainty. And so it gets worse, with the richest 2% of the world’s people now controlling over half the world’s wealth. Another problem is environmental. As there isn’t enough money to pay all the debts, the amount of lending must continually increase or people will default. Yet more and more lending requires more and more things to trade, which requires more and more consumption of our natural resources. In a world of limited resources our ingenuity is merely delaying the ultimate crash that’s been pro-programmed by our flawed money system.

Well that’s the theory. But lets see how it feels. Let me see your money. Take out some money! I’ve got a 20 euros. So you know its just paper right? [showed a 20 euro note]. As paper its not that useful to us. You could scribble something on it, maybe put it under your pillow and pray. Together we choose to make it mean something more than paper or metal and to be able to swap it for real goods and services. But its still just paper. [ripped the 20 euro note] It’s still just money [ripped again, falls on the floor]. We are the wealth… our skills, our desire to do stuff for each-other. Money, if designed for us, should simply be our mechanism for exchanging things of real value. So it is a delusion that money has value in itself . If we run our societies as if money is the goal, haven’t we gone completely mad? Yet turn on the TV and it seems we are pursuing economic growth – an increase in money – as if its the meaning of life.

I was so deluded I thought anyone talking about money in this way was a nutter. Perhaps you can relate to that now when listening to me…! My desire to be relevant, and my fear of being ridiculed, held me back from working on these issues. And I’ve come to recognise that the mass media, many of you guys, define what is relevant and what is ridiculous, and so play a key role in whether people are open to discussing the need for sustainable currencies. I searched and found that 42,000,000 webpages mention “financial crisis”. Guess how many of those pages mention “monetary reform”? 136,000, or just 0.3%. There is a massive silence, almost a taboo, on informed debate on monetary systems and what we can do about it. But what if media embraced its responsibility to challenge assumptions? What if media dug deeper? What if journalists asked top politicians “where does money come from?” You would get some funny replies. It could make good TV.

Fortunately, new media means independent voices can reach audiences of millions. Home-made films such as “Money as Debt” have been watched over a million times on youtube. And social media means campaigners for monetary reform and the innovators of new sustainable currencies can connect with each other. At the Finance Innovation Lab, co-run by WWF, participants have been sharing information on the latest initiatives. Ending the licence of private banks to create money from nothing, is one necessary reform. But we’re not holding our breath. Already, hundreds of thousands of people worldwide are trading in currencies that their own communities run, from slums in Rio and Nairobi, to business hubs in Brussels and Bristol. You can find our more, by searching for Timebanks in the US, the WIR in Switzerland, LETS in the UK, or Regiogeld in Germany. You could look up bitcoin, a digital currency that has become huge within a year. You could look at how some collaborative consumption websites, where neighbours share their stuff with each other, are now introducing their own currencies. New technology means we are on the verge of a massive leap in the volume of transactions using such currencies. Find those in your area of work or your town and we in our global village we might not need an Imperial Knight.

The emergence of new currencies that are not controlled by banks or governments, means we need to understand what kind of money systems are good for us. So that doesn’t mean going back to scarce metals as our money, or waiting for Facebook credits to become a new global private currency. A central principle must be that money be stable mechanism of exchange, that is issued as a public utility, and not for private profit.

The old money system has been ripping up our world, and appears even to be ripping itself to pieces [knelt down and gathered some of the euro pieces]. Yet with new technologies new forms of money are within our grasp. We can create and use sustainable currencies that weave together communities, not tear them apart. So we don’t need to kneel to the banks, [stood up] we can stand up for what we really value. We can end these crisis, starting by ending our delusions about money, and seeking real reform and using real alternatives.”

… it seemed to be well received. Come back to see the video! I will be making an art work out of the ripped 20 euro bill. My focus now is on communicating this more widely, researching the way large organisations can enagage in CCs, and other related stuff.

Thanks to Nadejda Loumbeva for the picture of me at tedx, and frenzypic Chris Hoefer for the pic of the Bank of International Settlements. Thx to Matthew, Ramin, Wolf, Beate, Bern, Ian, Folke, and Elaine for feedback in preparing the talk.

21 Responses to “TEDx Talk on the REAL cause of the Financial Crisis”

  1. An interesting perspective, Jem, and one that perhaps only few have appreciated. Thirty years ago, though, I made an off-the-cuff comment thus: Money will not rid us of problems; the problem is to be rid of money. Not being an economist, I had no idea at that time what the substitute should be, however. I still don’t, but your commentary has given me some hope that truly fundamental change might just have a probability greater than zero – considering, among other things, the financial mess globally.

    I’m not hopeful that change will come soon, though, despite the examples you have discussed. I say that because of the 2% who control half the world’s wealth, some of who will probably do anything to keep it – including the entrenched capitalist economy which serves as the privileged umbrella. Hence, while I think Karl Marx et al were right about their denunciation of the abuses of capitalism, I fail to see how any grassroots changes can affect its continued operation through all the global stock markets.

    Indeed, the great mass of the population is hampered by its dependency upon the trillions tied up in hedge funds and so on, upon which many depend for personal survival. Many have lost much of their savings, as you know.

    Whatever solutions are developed, whatever courses of action are put in motion, it will be a long haul, perhaps even generations.

  2. James said

    Definitely interesting thoughts Jem! I am curious to see what would happen if any of the alternative systems go mainstream.

  3. skanda42 said

    The major cause of the global protests is the political control of the money

    Governments has steadily worsened the situation

    The more intelligently the governments try to act, the more harm they seem to do – because once they are known to aim at particular goals (rather than merely maintaining a self-correcting spontaneous order) the less they can avoid serving sectional interests. And the demands of all organised group interests are almost invariably harmful.

    What is so dangerous and ought to be done away with is not governments’ right to issue money but the exclusive right to do so and their power to force people to use it and to accept it at a particular price. This monopoly of government, like the postal monopoly, has its origin not in any benefit it secures for the people but solely in the desire to enhance the coercive powers of government.

    Second, our policymakers, especially when given discretionary powers, are not necessarily benevolent, and cannot automatically be expected to use them to pursue “social good,” however defined. In essence, we should be looking for a set of institutions that would be robust to our ignorance and potentially self-seeking intentions of those who are in charge of the money supply.

    Central Banks create distortions

    Currently existing institutions that supply money to the economy are not satisfactory. Central banks, in their attempts to stimulate the economy, are likely to create distortions in the structure of production, leading to periods of investment booms and subsequent busts.

    Governments have always tended to monetise their debts, once these have reached certain levels. The acclaimed independence of central banks does not seem to be a binding constraint on this activity, especially not in bad economic times.

    Benefits of competition in issuing money

    The fundamental root of this problem is institutional: central banks are government-run monopolies and are not subject to the same competitive discipline as other business entities. There are no sound reasons why the supply of money ought to be monopolised and left in the government’s hands.

    Therefore, a system of competitive, privately issued currencies, would deliver a superior currency and also better outcomes in terms of macroeconomic stability.

    Competitive forces would thus force banks issuing money to behave in a more responsible way than central bankers can be expected to behave.

    Benefits of free currency system

    Make it merely legal and people will be very quick indeed to refuse to use the national currency once it depreciates noticeably, and they will make their dealings in a currency they trust.

    Employers, in particular, would find it in their interest to offer, in collective agreements, not wages anticipating a foreseen rise of prices but wages in a currency they trusted and could make the basis of rational calculation.

    This would deprive government of the power to counteract excessive wage increases, and the unemployment they would cause, by depreciating their currency.

    It would also prevent employers from conceding such wages in the expectation that the national monetary authority would bail them out if they promised more than they could pay

    The currently existing institutional structure through which central bankers can exercise discretion over the money supply and interest rates is deeply flawed and responsible for a variety of economic ills.

  4. drgizmo said

    Jem, I highly recommend Human Action, LVM has some of these same Ideas, basically economic systems must be for humans, and human speed, if we move away from fiat… we slow it all down, to a natural speed… not infinite speed as it now.

  5. […] and communities, is chewed up to service compound interest on perpetual debt. I explained in my TEDx talk in Rome last month that the solutions involve both monetary reform and scaling complementary currencies. […]

  6. Hi everyone, it’s my first go to see at this web site, and post is truly fruitful designed for me, keep up posting such posts.

  7. Keesha said

    Remarkable! Its truly amazing post, I have got much
    clear idea on the topic of from this editorial.

  8. After I originally left a comment I seem to have clicked the -Notify
    me when new comments are added- checkbox and from now on whenever a comment is added I
    get 4 emails with the exact same comment. Is there a means you are able to
    remove me from that service? Thanks!

  9. Hi, its core post on the topic of media print, we all know media is a enormous source of data.

  10. Sienna said

    Hi there to every one, since I am genuinely keen of reading this webpage’s post to be updated regularly. It carries crucial stuff.

  11. There are crucial dialogues on the topic of this editorial here at this web-site, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting here.

  12. Broderick said

    whoah this web-site is excellent i like reading your
    articles. Keep up the great work! You know, many individuals are searching round
    for this information, you can aid them greatly.

  13. Hello, Neat post. There is an issue along with
    your web site in internet explorer, might test this?
    IE still is the market leader and a huge section of peeps will leave out your wonderful writing because of this problem.

  14. Jeffry said

    Fine way of describing, and fastidious post to obtain data about my presentation topic,
    which i am going to convey in school.

  15. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this blog.
    I really hope to see the same high-grade content by you
    in the future as well. In fact, your creative writing
    abilities has motivated me to get my own blog now😉

  16. Went to copy from windows and attempted to paste onto an android app.
    Maybe I need to quit life.

  17. Could do with some more info on this – any thoughts as to who I might read or what sites I might go to?

  18. Hi, Neat post. There’s an issue along with your web site in web explorer, might test this? IE nonetheless is the marketplace chief and a good component to other people will miss your fantastic writing because of this problem.

  19. Wonderful read. cheers.

  20. There a wide range of reputable pet pharmacies offering pet medications online.
    Sites that offer unapproved, counterfeited medicines acquire
    minimal rankings. Take choose to preserve and help with
    the well-being of the plant community.

  21. Admiring the commitment you put into your blog
    and detailed information you present. It’s nice to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t
    the same outdated rehashed material. Great read! I’ve bookmarked
    your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: